Are bike lanes bad for the environment?
In general, I'm a major proponent of bike commuting: it's fun, it's cheap, and it's carbon-free -- isn't it? A San Francisco traffic activist thinks that bike lanes will actually hurt the city's air quality instead of help, and as much as it irks us, he may actually have a point. In the same way that London's congestion charge has resulted in more congestion, Rob Anderson believes that taking space away from cars to create bike lanes will only result in more idling cars in bumper to bumper traffic -- and fuel what he calls a "bicycle fantasy."
Since he persuaded a judge to halt SF's bike-friendly overhaul in 2006, he's been the object of scorn for all sorts of cycle advocacy groups. Despite the intuitive response that bike lanes are great, SF can't proceed with its bikeification until it has conducted a survey of the environmental impacts -- especially on congestion.
Not only do bikers feel they've been dealt an injustice because they're not the ones spewing carbon, but simple bike racks can't be put in place until after the survey is concluded. Bummer.
Anderson (who hasn't owned a car in 20yrs) contends that anti-car fanatics are willing to screw up traffic "on behalf of what he calls the "bicycle fantasy." In a way, he might be right -- but I still wouldn't want to be in his highly unpopular shoes right now. It's hard to be the guy who backs unpopular arguments. It also helps if you're not a jerk about it.
[via Treehugger]
It's Energy Independence Day! 
Green Your 4th of July Celebration
The Importance of Pollination - It's Not Just Bee Sex
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
8-23-2008 @ 10:44AM
Paulius said...
I don't agree at all that Bike lines are bad. It will take time for car drivers to change their mind and start using bikes.
Also each city should create fees for oil powered cars. This will help promote to buy new carbon free cars which should be a solution. Well this will take maybe 10 years but we have to start from somewhere.
Reply
9-03-2008 @ 12:20AM
M H Rizvi said...
No it will have a positive impact on pollution
Reply