Old car versus new car: Which is greener?
For the longest time now, I've had this dilemma concerning my vehicle and its carbon footprint. See, I drive a rather old car which doesn't really have any smog-reducing features. In fact, it was made before smog-reducing features were even created. Without going into the story of why I even own something like this, let's just say I'm "thrifty", and I have a fascination with old, original stuff that still works.To state my case, I drive my car maybe 10 miles a week. Working from home has afforded me this luxury, and living 2 blocks from a major street allows me to walk or bike to the grocery store when needed. I realize that when I am driving this car, the ozone layer is probably unzipping directly above me, so I need some opinions from the readers about this topic.
Is it better to repair an older vehicle in order to reuse and recycle it? Does the creation process of a new car have an eventually deeper carbon impact than the occasional use of an old one? I realize there are many determiners here, and I don't want to make this all about my own personal situation, but in general, would this be advantageous in your opinion?
There have been a few debates about this issue in the past, comparing the carbon output needed to create a Toyota Prius versus the efficiency of an older small car. These are extremely valid points, and the numbers don't lie. So through this research I've decided that I don't need to go all-out and replace my old clunker with a brand new car. A vehicle doesn't have to be brand new to be efficient, and in many cases, it's the better choice. So what are your thoughts?













Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
6-25-2008 @ 1:35PM
Chris Carpenter said...
Somebody will be driving your old car regardless. Just because you opt for a prius doesn't mean that your old car will turn into pixie dust and magically disappear. Americans are slowly going to wash their hands of gas guzzlers for their own sense of being absconded of ecoguilt...but you don't have to travel far (Mexico) to see where our big cars are ending up. In short, if you can retrofit, that's part of the Reduce, Reuse, Recycle model...not buying the latest greatest.
Reply