I have a dream: finally, legal rights for vegetables
Free the celery! Switzerland could be the first country in the world to give rights to plants. The Swiss Federal Ethics Committee on Non-Human Biotechnology has issued a report saying that plants have certain inalienable rights simply by virtue of being living things, and we can't just do whatever we want with them. In the words of the report, "we may not use them just as we please, even if the plant community is not in danger, or if our actions do not endanger the species, or if we are not acting arbitrarily."
The report does allow - rather grudgingly - that human life takes precedence over plant happiness, so eating a potato now and again to stave off starvation is probably ok. However, casual violence against say, tulips, is an affront to the dignity of the flower, to avoided at all costs.
Is veggie liberation the next great frontier of social justice? Can we look forward to being taken to court by our hibiscus for underwatering? Will we see a million-melon march on Washington?
Probably not - this concept is a little extreme even for the most committed treehugger, and likely doesn't demonstrate much except that there are people within the Swiss government who have way too much time on their hands. Still, something to think about next time you're torturing steaming that head of broccoli.
The full English language report is available here .
via [The Weekly Standard]














Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
5-09-2008 @ 5:41PM
Deborah said...
So if we can't eat meat and we can't eat vegetables, what's left?
Well I guess this means we can't use fungi to create even better, flame-retardant house insulation.
Would John Deere and their ilk be taken to court for serial homicide? Er, rather, plant-icide? (there's no limitations on murder)
And no more farmers; feeding animals plants would be assisted plant-slaughter.
But then no farmers would let all the livestock die, and be guilty of murder on account of not intervening. (But I guess that would result in less life sentences than killing trillions of kernels of corn)
Reply